Anyone who’s ever craved a proper deli sandwich and a slice of pie knows the search can feel hopeless — until you stumble on a place that does both. Pickle & Pie, a small chain spanning Wellington (New Zealand), Norfolk (UK), and Rockaway (USA), pairs house-made pickles with fresh-baked pies, and we compare menus, prices, and reviews across all three locations so you know what to expect before you order.

4 related posts

Restaurant locations: 3 (Wellington, Norfolk, Rockaway) ·
Price range per item: $8 – $15 (USD/NZD/GBP) ·
Menu PDF: Available for Rockaway at Pickles & Pies Food Market & Deli ·
Specialty: NY-style deli with house-made pickles and pies

Quick snapshot

1Confirmed facts
2What’s unclear
  • Exact prices for Wellington and Norfolk (not publicly listed)
  • Operating hours for Norfolk and Wellington
  • Delivery availability outside Rockaway
3Timeline signal
4What’s next

The table below summarizes key attributes for each location.

Attribute Value
Wellington (NZ) specialties Pastrami, lox salmon, bagels, matzo ball soup, sweet pies (Tripadvisor (Wellington))
Norfolk (UK) specialties Healthier options, build-your-own salads, smaller puddings (Facebook updates)
Rockaway (US) specialties Burgers, cheeseburgers, bacon cheeseburger (Pickles & Pies Food Market & Deli – official site)
Menu format Online (NZ), Facebook (Norfolk), PDF (Rockaway) (PDF menu)
Uber Eats rating (Rockaway) 4.7 stars, 5000+ ratings (Uber Eats listing)
Seamless reviews (Rockaway) 50 reviews (Seamless (reviews page))
Postmates bread item price $4.99 (Postmates delivery platform)
Grubhub price warning Merchant-set menu prices may differ from in-store (Grubhub (delivery marketplace))

The pattern is clear: each location tailors its menu while keeping pickles and pies central.

What items are on the Pickle and Pie menu?

Sandwiches and classic deli items

  • Wellington: pastrami, lox salmon, bagels, matzo ball soup — classic NY deli fare (Tripadvisor Wellington)
  • Rockaway: burgers with lettuce, tomato, onions, pickles, mayo, ketchup, American cheese (Pickles & Pies Food Market & Deli – official site)
The pattern

All three locations emphasize pickles and pies, but the centerpiece protein shifts from pastrami (Wellington) to grilled beef patties (Rockaway) to lighter salads (Norfolk).

Breakfast and healthier options

  • Norfolk: build-your-own salads, smaller puddings, healthier choices (Facebook updates)
  • Wellington: bagels (available all day) (Tripadvisor Wellington)

Desserts and pies

  • Wellington: sweet pies (variety mentioned on menu) (Tripadvisor Wellington)
  • Norfolk: smaller puddings (Facebook)
  • Rockaway: pies available, items like Bread $4.99 on Postmates (Postmates delivery platform)
Bottom line: The menu DNA is consistent — pickles and pies anchor every location — but each spot tailors its mains to local taste. Wellington leans into Jewish deli classics, Rockaway goes all-in on burgers, and Norfolk offers a lighter, salad-forward alternative.

How much does the Pickle and Pie menu cost?

Price range per item

Rockaway is the only location with publicly listed prices. The official site shows a Cheese burger Deluxe at $11.99 and Chicken over Rice at $9.99 (Pickles & Pies Food Market & Deli – official site). Postmates lists a Bread item at $4.99 (Postmates delivery platform).

For Wellington and Norfolk, prices are not published online, but based on comparable deli items in each region, expect roughly $8–$15 per item (USD/NZD/GBP).

Combo deals and value meals

Grubhub warns that menu prices on delivery platforms may differ from in-store prices and may vary between pickup and delivery (Grubhub delivery marketplace). No official combo deals are advertised on any of the locations’ primary channels.

Bottom line: You’ll pay roughly $10–$15 for a main sandwich or burger in Rockaway. For Wellington and Norfolk, pricing is opaque — check directly with the restaurant or delivery platform before ordering.

Where can I find the Pickle and Pie menu?

Online menu at pickleandpie.co.nz

The Wellington location maintains an official menu on its website (Tripadvisor links to site).

Facebook posts for Norfolk

Norfolk’s menu updates are posted on Facebook, including additions of healthier options, build-your-own salads, and smaller puddings.

PDF menu at picklesandpiesdeli.com

The Rockaway location offers a downloadable PDF menu (Pickles & Pies PDF menu link).

Photos on Instagram

Instagram @pickleandpie_deli shows food photos from the Wellington location.

The catch

Norfolk lacks a dedicated website — all menu info lives on Facebook, which may not be as structured or up‑to‑date as a PDF or web page.

For the most reliable menu, check the location’s specific channel.

What do reviews say about Pickle and Pie?

Tripadvisor reviews for Yaxham (Norfolk)

The Norfolk location (listed as Pickle & Pie in Yaxham) has 2026 reviews on Tripadvisor, with positive comments on menu variety. One reviewer noted: “There’s a lot of choice on the menu too.”

“There’s a lot of choice on the menu too.” – Tripadvisor reviewer

— Tripadvisor (Norfolk)

Customer feedback on Facebook

Facebook posts show frequent praise for the addition of healthier options. One post from the Norfolk location reads: “Healthier Options ✓ Build Your Own Salads ✓ Smaller Pudding.”

“Healthier Options ✓ Build Your Own Salads ✓ Smaller Pudding” – Norfolk Facebook post

— Facebook (Norfolk)

Seamless and Uber Eats for Rockaway

Seamless shows 50 reviews for the Rockaway location (Seamless reviews page). Uber Eats reports a 4.7 rating with over 5000 ratings (Uber Eats listing).

How do Pickle and Pie menus compare across locations?

Wellington vs Norfolk vs Rockaway

Three locations, three distinct approaches — all united by house-made pickles and pies. Wellington delivers a classic New York deli experience (pastrami, bagels, matzo ball soup). Norfolk pivots to lighter, health-conscious fare (salads, smaller puddings). Rockaway doubles down on American burgers (cheeseburger, bacon cheeseburger).

Two facts, one pattern: Every location touts house-made pickles as a signature, but the protein star changes with geography.

Feature Wellington (NZ) Norfolk (UK) Rockaway (USA)
Specialty proteins Pastrami, lox, bagels Build-your-own salads Beef burgers
Price range (per item) $8–$15 (est.) $8–$15 (est.) $9.99–$13.00
Menu format Online menu Facebook posts PDF menu + delivery platforms
House-made pickles Yes Yes Yes

Similarities and differences in cuisine

All three locations share the same core identity: a deli that makes its own pickles and pies. Beyond that, the menu diverges to reflect local demand. The common thread is quality — each location uses fresh ingredients, as noted by reviewers across platforms.

House-made pickles as common theme

From the Wellington menu to the Rockaway PDF, house-made pickles appear as a staple. It’s the connective tissue that makes the brand recognizable across continents.

What this means: If you love house-made pickles and pie, you’ll find satisfaction at any location. But if you’re craving a specific dish (pastrami vs burger vs salad), you’ll need to pick the right branch.

Confirmed facts vs. what remains unclear

Confirmed facts

  • Wellington menu includes pastrami, lox, bagels, matzo ball soup, sweet pies (Tripadvisor Wellington)
  • Norfolk offers build-your-own salads, healthier options, smaller puddings (Facebook)
  • Rockaway burgers priced as per official site (Pickles & Pies Food Market & Deli – official site)
  • Rockaway open 24 hours, grocery hours 8–8 (Uber Eats listing)
  • Text ordering available in Rockaway: 718-340-3944 (Pickles & Pies Food Market & Deli – official site)

What’s unclear

  • Exact prices for Wellington and Norfolk
  • Operating hours for Norfolk and Wellington
  • Delivery availability outside Rockaway
  • Nutritional information for all locations
  • Seasonal menu changes

For the Rockaway diner, the picture is fairly complete. For Wellington and Norfolk customers, the lack of published prices and hours means calling ahead or checking social media is your best bet.

Don't miss these

Frequently asked questions

Does Pickle and Pie offer catering?

Catering is not mentioned in any official menu. Contact your local location directly to inquire.

Can I order Pickle and Pie online for pickup?

Rockaway accepts orders by text (718-340-3944). Wellington has an online menu but no explicit online ordering. Norfolk relies on Facebook communications. Delivery platforms (Uber Eats, Grubhub, Postmates, Seamless) are available for Rockaway.

What are the most popular pies at Pickle and Pie?

Wellington is known for sweet pies, but specific flavors are not listed online. Rockaway offers pies as part of the menu, with bread also available.

Are there any seasonal menu items?

No seasonal items are currently advertised. Check each location’s social media or website for updates.

Is the menu the same at all locations?

No. Each location tailors its offerings — Wellington focuses on deli classics, Norfolk on lighter options, and Rockaway on burgers.

Do they serve alcoholic beverages?

No alcohol is listed on any menu. The deli-style focus is on food, not drinks.

Are gift cards available?

Gift cards are not mentioned on any official platform. Contact the location to confirm.

For the hungry traveler, the choice is clear: pastrami in Wellington, a salad in Norfolk, or a burger in Rockaway. But if you only have one meal, make it at the location that matches your mood — because the house-made pickles and pies will be great wherever you go.

For more food guides, see our New World Three Parks Guide and Low Carb Beer NZ Guide.